When considering items to consign, look for high-demand, well-maintained goods such as American Girl dolls, LEGO sets, comic books, baseball cards, and other sports memorabilia. These collectibles often hold strong resale value, especially when in good condition or rare. High-quality shoes and clothing from reputable brands, as well as unique holiday collectibles, are also great choices for consignment. Whether vintage or contemporary, items that are clean, authentic, and in good shape tend to attract more buyers and better prices.
We’re happy to consider consigning just about any item and always strive to provide honest, helpful feedback. Our goal is to help you get the best return possible—whether that means selling through us or pointing you in the right direction to sell it yourself. If an item isn’t the right fit for our shop, we’ll gladly offer guidance on alternative selling options, including tips on how to list, price, and present your item effectively. Your success is our priority, even if it happens outside of our store.
Ready to Consign?